Atención: Algunas o todas las identificaciones afectadas por esta división puede haber sido reemplazada por identificaciones de Brachycephaloidea. Esto ocurre cuando no podemos asignar automáticamente una identificación a uno de los taxa de salida. Revisar identificaciones de Craugastoridae 64732

Taxonomic Split 98550 (Guardado el 17/09/2021)

Several families split off

Amphibian Species of the World 6.0 (Referencia)
Añadido por loarie el 18 de septiembre de 2021 | Comprometido por loarie el 17 de septiembre de 2021
dividido en

Comentarios

Dear Laurie,
Are you confident this is the right taxonomic split at the right time? You cite as justification "Amphibian Species of the World 6.0 (Citation)", but that database reports almost all previous studies, many of which disagree with each other, so I am not clear on your motivation here. When I look up Craugastoridae in 'ASW' it seems to cite Padial et al. 2014 for this (or?), which may be a tad dated at this point. A very recent look at this question is our paper Barrientos et al. (2021) here:
http://dna.ac/PDFs/Barrientos&l_21_phylogenomics_terraranan_frogs_UCE_2665%20loci.pdf
that suggests Craugastoridae takes precedence over Strabomantidae. Our Fig. 1 summarizes the last 11 molecular phylogenetic studies of families within Terraranae, which shows just how unstable these results may be, sure enough, e.g., Hime et al. (2021) disagreeing with Hutter et al. (2017). So, I certainly could be wrong, but I think recognizing Strabomantidae might not be the be option at this time. Or why do you feel it is the best option?

Publicado por crawfordaj hace alrededor de 1 mes (Marca)

we try to follow ASW for amphibian taxonomy - I recommend you contact them (FYI @dfrost) to discuss various viewpoints. Its possible you can get them to return to Craugastoridae sensu lato or if you build up a strong consensus here we can always deviate. However, our philosophy is to follow eternal providers like ASW for taxonomy when we can

Publicado por loarie hace alrededor de 1 mes (Marca)

Agregar un comentario

Acceder o Crear una cuenta para agregar comentarios.